Are direct producer hybrids returning to the European wine market?

Brussels reopens the question of six banned American varieties: a French MEP wants to bring Noah, Isabella and Clinton back into winemaking

French Socialist Member of the European Parliament Éric Sargiacomo is trying to lift the ban on making wine from six American direct producer hybrids: Noah, Othello, Isabelle (Isabella), Jacquez, Clinton and Herbemont. Sargiacomo, who leads the Parliament’s negotiations on the revision of the EU rules on agricultural markets, now wants to write the change into the regulation on the common organisation of the markets for the period after 2027. The Council of the EU has already adopted its position on the regulation, while the Parliament is still preparing its own.

The current regulation stipulates that only varieties of the species Vitis vinifera or its crosses with other species of the genus Vitis may be classified, and the six varieties are explicitly excluded. They arrived from America in the 19th century and are associated with the arrival of diseases and pests such as phylloxera, to which they themselves are resistant. France banned them in the 1930s, in the middle of a wine overproduction crisis, and other European countries followed suit in the 1970s.

Old hillside vineyard

Sargiacomo calls the ban “outdated nonsense” and points out that these varieties are used in the USA, while wines made from them can already be freely imported and drunk in Europe.

The European wine industry naturally opposes the change, because these varieties mostly have very high yields, which could affect overall production. Wines made from them also depart from the usual sensory profile and often have the so-called foxy taste and a musky aroma reminiscent of grape juice. There have been similar initiatives before, but a coalition of France, Italy and Spain blocked them.

In Croatia, Isabella and Noah are still grown in home gardens, but wine made from them cannot legally be sold. The 2019 Wine Act stipulates that Croatian wines are made from recognised cultivars and that vines may only be planted from cultivars on the National List, and neither Isabella nor Noah appears on the list in the Ordinance on Viticulture. Even if the EU lifted the ban, these varieties would first have to be added to the National List before their wine could reach the market in Croatia.

Prvi smo izbor informacija o vinima onima koji tek ulaze u vinski svijet, onima koji ga već smatraju svojim, onima koji u njemu istinski žive i onima koji ga stvaraju.